Monday, April 30, 2007
The Problem of Nationalism
The very first story I covered, the murder of Hrant Dink and its aftermath, served as my introduction to Turkish nationalism. Hrant Dink was a Turkish-Armenian who edited a weekly paper, the Argos, in which he frequently discussed the so-called Armenian genocide. This genocide, perpetrated by the Ottoman Empire, took place during World War I and is estimated to have resulted in the death of approximately one million Armenians. To this day, Turkey denies that any genocide took place and takes any implication that it did as an insult to the nation. Hrant Dink’s murder was a result of this nationalist feeling, and so provided an accurate, if tragic, introduction to this phenomenon.
The next major story I covered was the Turkish reaction to the Armenian genocide bill that was introduced into the United States House of Representatives. This nonbinding resolution would officially label the Ottoman’s actions during World War II as genocide. Naturally, Turkey was unhappy with any discussion of such a bill, seeing it as an insult on their nationalist pride. They went so far as to send Foreign Minister Gul to the United States threatening irreparable damage to American-Turkish relations should the bill become law.
The final major story I have covered had to do with the Kurdish problem in northern Iraq. Northern Iraq contains several different ethnic groups, including Turks. So when Barzani, the leader of the Kurds in Iraq laid claim to the city of Kirkuk, and warned Turkey not to interfere, Turkey reacted negatively. Obviously, Turkish nationalism extends beyond the borders of the country and to their ethnic groups in other countries.
I think it is apparent that all countries have a certain amount of nationalistic pride. In my coverage of Turkey, however, it seems that this nationalism can also be a very damaging force. For example, in the Hrant Dink story this nationalist spirit led not only to the murder of an innocent man, but also a celebration of this murder by the police force that were supposed to be investigating the matter. The incident with the Armenian genocide bill is another case in point. Though the bill was nonbinding, and practically harmless, Turkey was prepared to break relations with a powerful ally. Finally, the debate over the city of Kirkuk, though influenced by other considerations, also has an element of nationalism that could possibly increase the instability of the already shaky country of Iraq.
In recounting what I have discovered while covering the nation of Turkey, I do not mean to criticize their nationalist spirit. Rather, I feel it is a good way to draw attention to the nationalist spirit that exists in every nation, even though the members of that nation may not be aware of it. Once we are aware that nationalism exists within our own country, we should be able to avoid the damaging consequences that accompany an excess of national pride. I feel that my coverage of the nation of Turkey has led not to contempt for their nationalist spirit, but to a realization of my own nationalism, and the ability to critique my opinions based on this newfound knowledge.
Nationalism in Turkey Leads to Murder, Intrigue
This genocide, perpetrated by the Ottoman Empire, took place during World War I and is estimated to have resulted in the death of approximately one million Armenians through forced deportations, among other means. While many other nations recognize that genocide took place, and some have even attempted to officially recognize it, Turks today still deny that any genocide took place due to their strong feelings of nationalism.
It was these feelings of nationalism that fueled Dink’s murderer, a 17-year old youth named Ogun Samast, as well as the others involved, including Yasin Hayal, who provided Samast with a gun.
National pride also took precedent over police duties. Soon after the murder, pictures were leaked to the press showing officers posing with Ogun Samast in front of a Turkish flag. It was further discovered that police had ignored numerous warnings regarding an attempt on Dink’s life.
The appearance of these pictures and the apparent police inaction regarding warnings has led many to believe that the “deep state” may be involved in the matter. The term “deep state” is used to refer to radical nationalists working undercover within the state and willing to do anything to prevent what they perceive as threats to the nation of Turkey. The Prime Minister of Turkey, Tayyip Erdogan referred to the deep state as “gangs within the state institutions,” and pledged to bring those working outside the law to justice.
As evidenced by Prime Minister Erdogan’s resolve, the aftermath of the murder was not entirely negative. 100,000 mourners, most of them Turks, attended Hrant Dink’s funeral, chanting phrases such as “We are all Hrant Dink” and “We are all Armenian.” Furthermore, the Turkish government, and especially Prime Minister Erdogan, made a strong effort to crack down on those involved in the murder, as well as the ultra-nationalist sentiment behind it. Seven men, including the murderer were immediately placed in custody, several gendarmes were transferred, and the Istanbul Police Intelligence Chief who ignored the warnings was suspended from his duties.
The Turkish government also showed a surprising amount of respect to the Armenian Orthodox church. When Patriarch Mesrob II, head of the Turkish branch of the church, criticized the government for not finding who was really behind the murder the government responded by launching a new wave of questioning.
Of course, some extreme nationalist sentiment still exists in the nation of Turkey. Soon after Dink’s funeral anti-Armenian banners and chants could be found in soccer stadiums across the nations, including the slogans “We are Turks” and “We are not Armenians.” The government, however, was swift to respond to these incidents, and it is hoped that the aftermath of Dink’s murder will in fact lead to better relations between Turkey and Armenia.
Tensions Rise Between Turks and Kurds
Date: Wednesday, April 11, 2007 1:53pm
Tensions between Turkey and the Kurdish region in northern Iraq have recently increased, to a possibly dangerous level. The tensions come as a result of comments made by Barzani, who is president of the Kurdish regional government in northern Iraq. Barzani, in a television interview, warned Turkey not to interfere with Kurdish plans to claim the oil-rich city of Kirkuk as part of the Kurdish region, and threatened Kurdish intervention in southeast Turkey should they not listen, saying “There are 30 million Kurds in Turkey and we don't interfere there. If they [the Turks] interfere in Kirkuk over just thousands of Turkmen then we will take action for the 30 million Kurds in Turkey.”
Turkey took immediate offense at this statement, leading to several issued statements and plans by the Turkish government. Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul contacted Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, requesting the US warn Barzani about his statements, telling her “Make this man quiet. The things he says are unacceptable.” Turkey’s Foreign Ministry also sent the new Iraqi government a strong note, which caused President Jelal Talabani to phone Prime Minister Erdogan in an attempt to defuse the situation.
US State Department spokesman Sean McCormack labeled Barzani’s statements as “really unhelpful” and “not further[ing] the goal of greater Turkish-Iraqi cooperation.” The US hopes to keep things low key due to the upcoming Turkish elections, which take place during spring, a time when the PKK usually goes on the offensive.
Moving beyond pure diplomacy, Turkey also hinted at economic sanctions against Iraq, unless Iraq is able to slow Kurdish attacks from across their border. “Political, economic and other approaches…were evaluated.” There is even talk of closing the border between the two countries, which would cut off a large amount of supplies for the Kurds in Iraq.
The Turkish Daily News also reported that Turkey was considering a military option against PKK camps located in northern Iraq at a meeting of the National Security Council. The US, Iraq, and the EU are all opposed to such a plan. Turkey understood the international concern, but responded that Barzani and the PKK have limited their options. The Security Council also asked Iraq to do their part in moving against the PKK, stating that “if Iraq is not able to do so, it is Turkey’s right, based on international law, to protect its borders.”
Hurriyet
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/6298072.asp?gid=74
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/6305063.asp?gid=74
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=70274
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=70357
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=70422
Washington Post
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/10/AR2007041001233.html
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/09/AR2007040901328.html
Turkey Unhappy With Russian Oil Pipeline
Author: Michael Tighe
Date: Wednesday, April 4, 2007 12:54pm
On March 16, Al Jazeera reported that Russia had agreed with Greece and Bulgaria on an oil pipeline that would bring Russian oil to the Mediterranean area. The pipeline will be constructed in such a way that it will avoid the Bosphorus Strait in Turkey. Fifty-one percent of the pipeline will be owned by Russia, and it will be capable of transporting 700,000 barrels of oil per day. Some analysts in Europe, however, worry that Russia already supplies the continent with too much, and are worried about the possibility of dependency on Russian oil.
Just recently, the Turkish Daily News reported the story, but from a Turkish point of view. Turkey, it appears, is worried that the Russian project is an attempt to block the Nabucco natural gas pipeline, which is designed to transport natural gas from Central Asia to Europe through Turkey, in an attempt to diversify suppliers. The Hungarian government, originally part of the Nabucco project, recently agreed to purchase gas from the Russian pipeline. Turkey, however, was optimistic that Hungary would not violate EU policy, but called for the EU to put pressure on Hungary to continue with the Nabucco project.
Turkey’s vested interest in these oil pipelines stems from their desire to become a credible member of the European Union. Not only do they see the Russian pipeline as a threat to the Nabucco pipeline, but they worry that any Russian pipeline which needs Turkey’s contribution will “[threaten] the Turkish position to be a credible transport country.”
The U.S. and other Western countries are expected to also respond to the Russian pipeline.
Al Jazeera
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/30C534FE-CD52-444E-B3F6-5CC2D2E4B7BD.htm?
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=69768
New York Times
http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F50E15FE34550C758DDDAA0894DF404482
Wednesday, April 25, 2007
Women With Mustaches
Date: Wednesday, March 28, 2007 2:14pm
In a rather humorous way to attract attention to the lack of important female politicians in Turkish politics, several female celebrities have donned mustaches and launched a marketing campaign. In addition, the Association for Educating and Supporting Women Candidates (KA-DER) has managed to snowball this into $10 million worth of advertising, while paying only $100,000 for the various television and newspaper ads, as well as billboards. More women are joining the campaign, which plans to continue until the elections take place.
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=69134
Turkish Government Still Pursuing Murderers
Date: Wednesday, March 28, 2007 2:14pm
Proving that the outrage over the murder of Hrant Dink was not merely a façade, the Turkish government continues to pursue those responsible. This Monday, Al Jazeera reported that Turkish police held Yasar Cihan, who is the head of a local branch of the Great Unity party.
Cihan admitted to helping Yasin Hayal, suspected as one of the main instigators, while Hayal was in prison. According to Cihan, however, “Almost everyone in Trabzon knew these people planned to murder Hrant Dink. I tried to reach them to stop the act but failed.” Yasan’s son was also detained for questioning, and is reported as having said that he did not believe that Tuncel could have instigated the murder.
The most recent wave of questioning came after Patriarch Mesrob II, head of the Armenian Orthodox church in Turkey, criticized the government for failing to uncover who was really behind the murder of Hrant Dink.
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=69312
Al Jazeera
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/1FF5F5C3-D307-4022-9593-AAA362B895EA.htm?
YouTube Banned for Short Period in Turkey
Date: Wednesday, March 21, 2007 2:02pm
Due to a court order, the site YouTube was blocked across the nation of Turkey. Internet users seeking access to the site from the country were met with this message: "Access to this site has been blocked by a court decision.” This ban resulted from a video posted on YouTube calling the Turkish people, and specifically Ataturk “homosexual.” The court also found that there were curse words in English on both the Turkish flag and photos of Ataturk. YouTube apologized for the offensive video, and had it removed soon after, which prompted the court to revoke the ban two days later.
Several days later the Turkish Daily News reported that the mother of the Greek student Kostas Papafloratos, whose nickname was used to upload the video, blamed an English hacker for posting the video. Interpol is now investigating.
Al Jazeera
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/D2245E90-28FC-4722-B96D-727D2CA869AF.htm?
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=68049
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=67977
Mayor of Hakkari Jailed
Date: Wednesday, March 21, 2007 2:02pm
Metin Tekce, mayor of Hakkari, has been sentenced to seven years in jail for belonging to the outlawed Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) and for saying that the PKK is “not a terrorist organization.” The Turkish government blames the PKK for more than 30,000 deaths, since it began fighting for an ethnic homeland for the Kurds in 1984. It is not clear whether Tekce, who was in France during the trial, will return to serve the seven years or will appeal the ruling.
Both Al Jazeera and Turkish Daily News are reporting that numerous other officials of the pro-Kurdish Democratic Society Party (DTP) are being brought to court on charges of praising the PKK or its imprisoned leader, Abdullah Ocalan.
The ruling also comes just before the largest Kurdish festival of the year, Nevroz, celebrating a new year and the beginning of spring. This festival has often led to conflict between Kurdish separatist and Turkish security forces. In an attempt to stop any violence are calling for “commonsense” during the demonstrations, noting that no illegal demonstrations are going to be tolerated. Prime Minister Erdogan also made attempts to promote peaceful celebration, referring to the Kurds as “brothers.”
The Hurriyet reports that the Turkish Interior Ministry has banned “the display of any banners or posters at Nevruz celebrations other than those bearing the symbol of the Turkish flag.” In a separate story, however, the Hurriyet details early demonstrations featuring PKK slogans and banners. These were supposedly sponsored by the DTP in the town of Yuksekova, which is outside of Hakkari, the town whose mayor has been sentenced to jail.
Al Jazeera
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/2F76EE97-629B-46D4-96FE-86E5DB0B9982.htm?
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=68671
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=68749
Hurriyet
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/6168944.asp?gid=74
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/6172035.asp?gid=74
More Opposition to Armenian Genocide Bill
Date: Wednesday, March 7, 2007 1:52pm
Turkey is currently meeting with the U.S. Black Muslim leader, Deen Mohammed, for a number of reasons, including preventing a clash of civilizations and to lobby against the Armenian genocide bill that is currently in the US House of Representatives. The main thrust of Mohammed’s visit appears to be a reinterpretation of Islam to fit better with the modern world, beginning with the importance of education.
Deen, the leader of approximately two million Muslims in the U.S. also stated that both Muslims and Jews are prepared to work together to lobby against the Armenian Genocide Bill. He made note of Keith Ellison, a deputy in Congress, and also stated that Barack Obama is an important individual in preventing genocide claims in the U.S.
Meanwhile, the Turkish Daily News reports that Armenia is growing concerned about the chances of the bill, due to Turkish lobbying against it. Armenia’s Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanian visited Washington D.C. on Monday to discuss the matter, saying he felt compelled to do so because of Turkey’s active stance.
Armenian newspapers remain surprisingly quiet on the matter. A small report from Panorama, an Armenian information portal, suggests that the bill is an attempt to sway Armenia’s attitude towards Iran. The author, a political scientist, stated that the bill would have no such effect, noting that: “The United States is a country thousand miles away from Armenia whereas Iran is our neighbor and we are connected with century long friendship.”
In addition, another Turkish newspaper, the Hurriyet, picked up on an op-ed piece in the Washington Post, which argued that Turkey should not take the Congressional vote on the Armenian Genocide Bill seriously. The Hurriyet, however, pays less attention to the argument that a non-binding resolution should merely be shrugged off, and instead focuses on the reasons why the bill is being pushed through, and especially the ignorance of the members of the House of Representatives on the matter.
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=67717
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=67652
Hurriyet
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/6071125.asp?gid=74
Panorama
http://www.panorama.am/en/politics/2007/03/06/iran/
Washington Post
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/03/04/AR2007030401047.html
Possible Tensions Brewing Over Northern Iraq
Date: Wednesday, February 28, 2007 1:27pm
Tensions regarding the findings of the United State’s Iraq Study Group are on the rise. The 22-member Arab League claims that the report “tramples on the rights of Iraquis.” Israel also appeared unhappy, as its leading newspaper charged that the report ignored Israel.
The Kurds, living in the Kurdistan region of northern Iraq, were the most outspoken about the reports findings, particularly because it gave Iraq’s central government control of the nation’s natural resources. The president of the Iraqi Kurdistan region, Massoud Barzani claimed the report was trying to institute the “wrong solutions” and declared that the panel was “in no way abiding by this report.”
Barzani also claimed that the oil-rich city of Kirkuk was the “heart of Kurdistan.” Turkey’s Prime Minister Tayyip Erdoðan was quick to respond, saying “such an attitude is very wrong with regards to Iraq’s future….Statements on this issue should be carefully made.”
Barzani, however, made the same claim later on, and added that Iran and Turkey needed to get used to the idea of an independent Kurdish state. He also went on to deny that the Kurds in northern Iraq were supportive of the PKK, and called for talks to ease the tension over that matter.
Al Jazeera
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/0EB739BD-DAD0-42F7-8B05-7288F211EE5E.htm?FRAMELESS=true&NRNODEGUID=%7b0EB739BD-DAD0-42F7-8B05-7288F211EE5E%7d
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=67155
Turkey Continues to Focus on US Armenian Genocide Bill
Date: Wednesday, February 21, 2007 1:47pm
A bill currently before the United States House of Representatives has the leaders of Turkey disgruntled. The bill in question brands the killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War I as genocide, which Turkey adamantly denies.
Turkey’s Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul warned that if such a bill passed it “would set back Turkish-American ties and hurt U.S. interests.” Prime Minister Erdogan was also unhappy, stating that “I am worried this would cast a shadow over our strategic partnership in the future.” Erdogan went on to say that he did not expect the bill to pass through the House of Representatives.
This is not the first time that Turkey has faced this situation, however. The US has brought similar bills up before, though one has never passed. It is seen as more of a threat this time because of Democratic support in Congress.
Other countries have also passed, or attempted to pass, similar legislation. France’s lower house passed a similar bill in 2006, prompting threats of boycotting from Turkey, but the bill never became law.
Though the bill is still a large issue in Turkey, American newspapers have been strangely silent about the matter, which seems odd, considering the importance of the two countries relations.
Turkish Press
http://www.turkishpress.com/news.asp?id=163453
Khaleej Times
http://www.khaleejtimes.com/DisplayArticleNew.asp?xfile=data/theworld/2007/February/theworld_February549.xml§ion=theworld&col=
(link now dead)
Al Jazeera
http://english.aljazeera.net/News/Archive/Archive?ArchiveID=36789
(link now dead)
Washington Post
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/10/AR2007021000618.html
(link now dead)
Editor's Murder Continues to Spark Controversy
Date: Wednesday, February 7, 2007 1:37pm
The murder of Hrant Dink continues to make its effect felt throughout the nation of Turkey. It has even involved Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoðan and the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) exchanging heated statements regarding each others positions. Prime Minister Erdoðan claimed that the nationalists were not nationalist, but “racist, discriminatory and skull measurers.” The MHP Deputy Chairman Mehmet Sandir responded, going so far as to claim that the prime minister holds “hostile emotions and opinions…toward the Turkish nation.”
Controversy also continued at local levels, as pictures were leaked to the press that apparently showed police officers posing with murderer Ogün Samast and a Turkish flag. The Turkish Daily News reports that Istanbul Police Intelligence Chief Ahmet Ýlhan Güler was suspended today, making him the seventh officer suspended during this investigation. Other sources report that several gendarmes have also been transferred due to the incident.
The appearance of these pictures and the apparent police inaction regarding warnings has led many to believe that the “deep state” may be involved in the matter. The “deep state” is used to refer to radical nationalists working within the state willing to do anything to prevent perceived threats to Turkey.
Prime Minister Erdoðan defines it as “gangs within state institutions.” In a recent speech, he declared that “we have put a stick in their [the deep state’s] wheel.” He pledged to continue fighting the problems within the institutions, but with restraint, so as to keep the institutions intact. Though these deep state individuals claim to be saving Turkey, PM Erdogan stated that “nothing can justify the violation of laws.”
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=65466
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=65546
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=65608
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=65485
Hurriyet
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/5887672.asp
Zaman
http://www.todayszaman.com/tz-web/detaylar.do?load=detay&link=102206
Washington Post
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/06/AR2007020600193.html
Armenian Editors Murder Continues to Provoke Response
Date: Wednesday, January 31, 2007 1:18pm
The murder of Hrant Dink, the editor of the Turkish-Armenian Argos, has provoked waves of responses throughout the nation of Turkey. Dink, an Armenian, was a controversial figure due to his open denouncement of Turkish killings of Armenians in 1915. At least seven men have been charged in relation to the murder, including the 17-year-old gunman, Ogün Samast and the man who supplied him with it, Yasin Hayal.
Fallout from the killing continues to build, however. The Hurriyet claims that Trabzon police were warned a total of 17 times, but that they only informed the Istanbul police once. The Turkish Daily News appears to confirm the story, noting that the Istanbul police were warned of an attempt to be made on Dink’s life, but after a short follow-up they abandoned the lead. As a result, both the governor and the police chief of Trabzon have been dismissed.
But the impact goes far beyond the political realm, and into the public. The Middle East Times reports that an estimated 100,000 people marched at the funeral of Dink, many of them chanting “We are all Hrant Dink. We are all Armenians.” Many see this as a step forward in Turkish-Armenian relations, which have been unpleasant, to say the least.
Strong nationalism still continues, however, as displayed in many soccer stadiums over the past couple of days. Many fans held banners displaying the words “We are all Turks,” and “We are not Armenians.” Such banners provoked a response from Deputy Prime Minister Mehmet Ali ªahin, who urged action against such behavior, noting that his ministry will be monitoring the results.
Turkish Daily News
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=65079
http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=65099
Hurriyet
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/5868673.asp?gid=74
Middle East Times
http://www.metimes.com/storyview.php?StoryID=20070120-060302-2363r
Washington Post
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/01/31/AR2007013100723.html