Monday, April 30, 2007

The Problem of Nationalism

During the course of the semester I have been reporting on major events that occur in the nation of Turkey. Looking back over these reports, I have realized that there is a common thread running through all the major stories that I have covered. To put it briefly, my coverage of Turkey has led me to the realization of how large of a role nationalism plays in Turkey’s affairs, both domestic and foreign, and how damaging this nationalism can be to those affairs.

The very first story I covered, the murder of Hrant Dink and its aftermath, served as my introduction to Turkish nationalism. Hrant Dink was a Turkish-Armenian who edited a weekly paper, the Argos, in which he frequently discussed the so-called Armenian genocide. This genocide, perpetrated by the Ottoman Empire, took place during World War I and is estimated to have resulted in the death of approximately one million Armenians. To this day, Turkey denies that any genocide took place and takes any implication that it did as an insult to the nation. Hrant Dink’s murder was a result of this nationalist feeling, and so provided an accurate, if tragic, introduction to this phenomenon.

The next major story I covered was the Turkish reaction to the Armenian genocide bill that was introduced into the United States House of Representatives. This nonbinding resolution would officially label the Ottoman’s actions during World War II as genocide. Naturally, Turkey was unhappy with any discussion of such a bill, seeing it as an insult on their nationalist pride. They went so far as to send Foreign Minister Gul to the United States threatening irreparable damage to American-Turkish relations should the bill become law.

The final major story I have covered had to do with the Kurdish problem in northern Iraq. Northern Iraq contains several different ethnic groups, including Turks. So when Barzani, the leader of the Kurds in Iraq laid claim to the city of Kirkuk, and warned Turkey not to interfere, Turkey reacted negatively. Obviously, Turkish nationalism extends beyond the borders of the country and to their ethnic groups in other countries.

I think it is apparent that all countries have a certain amount of nationalistic pride. In my coverage of Turkey, however, it seems that this nationalism can also be a very damaging force. For example, in the Hrant Dink story this nationalist spirit led not only to the murder of an innocent man, but also a celebration of this murder by the police force that were supposed to be investigating the matter. The incident with the Armenian genocide bill is another case in point. Though the bill was nonbinding, and practically harmless, Turkey was prepared to break relations with a powerful ally. Finally, the debate over the city of Kirkuk, though influenced by other considerations, also has an element of nationalism that could possibly increase the instability of the already shaky country of Iraq.

In recounting what I have discovered while covering the nation of Turkey, I do not mean to criticize their nationalist spirit. Rather, I feel it is a good way to draw attention to the nationalist spirit that exists in every nation, even though the members of that nation may not be aware of it. Once we are aware that nationalism exists within our own country, we should be able to avoid the damaging consequences that accompany an excess of national pride. I feel that my coverage of the nation of Turkey has led not to contempt for their nationalist spirit, but to a realization of my own nationalism, and the ability to critique my opinions based on this newfound knowledge.

No comments: